
The EFF has an excellent article about President Obama's gift to Queen Elizabeth: an iPod filled with music and video.
Article here.
If the gift were physical copies of the items (e.g. if he wanted to give her DVDs that would not play in her DVD player, as he did with Gordon Brown), then there is no question that the first sale doctrine applies. However, in this post-Napster era, copyright owners seem to have gone completely insane with attempting to impose control over digital distribution. The man on the street can tell you that this is folly, but they persist nonetheless.
Just for reference, I think that content producers should get paid for their art. That does not generate any love for the RIAA, the record companies, or the other racketeers that make up the current copyright thugs.
Image above licensed under creative commons.
Read more...
Monday, April 6, 2009
Why I think the copyright system is broken, an anecdote
Posted by
Bradley
at
10:02 AM
0
comments
Tuesday, October 30, 2007
Ron Paul Spam an attempt to block campaign email?
After writing my previous article about the email spam advertising the 2008 Ron Paul presidential campaign, I was left wondering: why?
Why would someone use a method so polarizing as spam in a popularity contest? The tinfoil beanie wearer in me came up with a very insidious reason.
So let's say that you are an opponent of Ron Paul, and you want to limit his reach. Where is his campaign most effective? That's right, online. You can't block his campaigners on digg, et al., but maybe you can prevent email.
No really, and here's how it works:
Send out all of Ron Paul's campaign ideas, use his bumper sticker phrases: "Ron Paul has never voted for a tax increase", and make double sure that the email will get caught as spam.
About Bayesian Filters
Now, most people who have used anti-spam tools have probably heard of a Bayesian Filter, but what you may not realize is that Bayesian Filters are subject to poisoning. You've seen this before, in spam that seems to have unusual strings of semantically incoherent words, or direct quotes from the news or literary sources. This is an attempt to "trick" a bayesian filter.
What you may or may not remember is that most of this was preceded by mail that looked similar, but contained no actual advertisement. This was an attempt at pre-training the bayesian filter to accept the later spam.
How does this effect legitimate mail?
Now back to the Ron Paul spam: if these mails are caught as spam (and they are a very obvious form of spam-- any spam filter should catch it, and MessageGate certainly nails the headers), then the phrases contained in the email get added to the bayesian spam bucket" and are henceforth used as indicators of spam. Then, when the Ron Paul campaign sends out a legitimate mail (say, one that you actually asked for), it will be categorized as spam by the bayesian filter.
That would be particularly devastating to a campaign that seems to be almost entirely dependent on the Internet.
I'm not saying that this is actually what happened, but it's interesting to think about.
Read more...
Posted by
Bradley
at
7:19 AM
1 comments
Labels: email, email governance, messagegate, politics, Ron Paul, spam
Monday, October 29, 2007
Ron Paul Spam
I wrote about the Ron Paul fan club earlier.
I've been around since Canter and Siegel offered me a chance at the green card lottery, but this is novel:
Message-ID: <000701c81a53$0156f27e$3360289e@yeibw>
From: --obscured--
To: byoung
Subject: ***SPAM*** Ron Paul Eliminates The IRS! XqvMlJY
Date: Mon, 29 Oct 2007 15:56:37 +0000
MIME-Version: 1.0
Hello Scott,
Ron Paul is for the people, unless you want your children to
have human implant RFID chips, a National ID card and create
a North American Union and see an economic collapse far worse
than the great depression. Vote for Ron Paul he speaks the
truth and the media and government is afraid of him. This is
the last honest politican left to bring this country out of
this rut from the War Profiteers and bush Administration has
created. Get motivated America, don't believe the lies of the
media he has also WON the GOP Debate On Sunday! Value Freedom
and Liberty instead of corporate lies and corruption. Bypass
this media blackout they are doing to Ron Paul, tell your family
and friends and get involved in a local group at meetup.com make
your voice heard! He will end the War In Iraq immediately,
He will eliminate the IRS and wasteful government spending, and
eliminate the Federal Reserve and restore power to the people
and the only person not a member on the CFR. Can any other runner
make these claims or give Americans the true freedom we were all
raised to believe? We are all economic slaves to the banks and the
illegal federal Reserve. This is why our currency is worth nothing
because of Hidden Inflation Tax and the IRS taking everything
you make!
** RON PAUL WILL STOP THE IRAQ WAR IMMEDIATELY! **
He has NEVER voted:
* to raise taxes
* for an unbalanced budget
* to raise congressional pay
* for a federal restriction on gun ownership
* to increase the power of the executive branch
He HAS voted:
* against the Iraq war
* against the inappropriately named USA PATRIOT act
* against regulating the internet
* against the Military Commissions Act
He will eliminate the IRS, Wasteful Government Spending &
Stop The Iraq War Immediately!
Most importantly, he voted NO on anything in Congress that
is not allowed by the Constitution. And he Despises any
politican that does not do their job for the people and lives
up to the constitution!
Google.com & Youtube.com Search: "Ron Paul"
Join The Revolution!
***************************************
We Need A Real President That Will Restore And Protect
Americans! Stop The War! Protect Our Borders!
*********VOTE RON PAUL 2008************
RqWjdM
Editors note: I work at a company that produces anti-spam solutions.
Now from the purely technical point of view, this is a rather obvious spam-- there are definite telltales in the received lines (which is why I didn't get this message at my work account-- we screen for false headers). This came in on my "canary in the coal mine" account, which isn't listed anywhere, and I never use, except to receive spam.
Dr. Paul's supporters are well known at this point for being very active on digg and the like (to the point that many have accused them of spamming), but this is really a new low.
I hope that these political spams get a little more sophisticated (since we all know they will continue, now that they've started), starting with: please don't send mail with 500 words in one paragraph.
Read more...
Posted by
Bradley
at
6:25 PM
0
comments
Labels: email, email governance, non-business email, politics, spam
Friday, October 26, 2007
More troubling breathalyzer news
I have written previously about the Minnesota case where the company that manufactures breathalyzers is being required to produce the source code for the device in a drunk driving case (here and here).
By way of disclaimer, I do not condone the practice of drunk driving, and believe that current penalties are at least 1-2 orders of magnitude too light. Additionally, I'm focused on US law.
An article in the Seattle Post Intelligencer has, in my mind, clarified quite succinctly why we should require open availability of specifications, design documents, and source code for any software or hardware device that is used as evidence in a court of law. From the article:
In a widely anticipated decision, the Skagit County District Court judges found examples of careless or potentially flawed work done by state scientists and evidence that three people -- including state toxicologist Barry Logan -- committed misconduct.Here's why we should have access to the designs, specifications, and implementation information:
In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defense. (emphasis mine)
That's the sixth amendment to the U.S. Constitution.
How do you cross-examine a device? How do you confront this "witness"?
You look at three things:
- Its design. The design may be flawed, intentionally or unintentionally.
- Its implementation. This is where the hardware and software (firmware) can be tested to verify correct function.
- The device itself. Is the device used for the test operating correctly?
Imagine that there's this magical box that can decide your innocence or guilt. Whether you go to prison or not. Whether you are branded criminal.
It is truly amazing to me that we are willing to trust a device without truly verifying it. As though it has some magical power to discern. Maybe we're just too willing to trust that a commercial entity is going to produce a perfect device, or that they are "experts".
The reality of the industry is that there are a lot of mediocre developers, managers, testers and processes. The reality is that deadline pressures cause inadequate testing. The reality is that th "expert" implementer may have taken 6 weeks of Java training before starting work on the software in question.
I know that seems harsh, but it is a reality in the software industry.
Hence the need for openness. Read more...
Posted by
Bradley
at
9:05 AM
0
comments
Labels: evidence, politics, programming
Thursday, August 16, 2007
The Ron Paul fan club
This is not about politics.
While I have to admit that Mike Huckabee definitely has impressed me with his bass playing (which is decent, but more marked by the fact that he plays a "semi-boutique"** bass-- a Tobias. He's even on YouTube.)
I'm also amused that John Edwards has decided that Men Who Look Like Kenny Rogers is part of his core demographic.
But I've been really interested by the grass roots campaigning of the Ron Paul campaign (and supporters). More thoughts after the jump.
If you have any exposure to the blogosphere, you've likely heard of Ron Paul.
You can't have read Digg lately without finding a reference to him.
What is interesting to me is that this all seems to be a rather deliberate and purposeful effort. It looks like a very organized grassroots effort to provide their candidate with coverage that I doubt that the mainstream media would have provided.
Our generation now has the Internet as one of the primary influencers of thought, and one campaign seems to have really capitalized on that. I suspect that the cost for this extra boost in "market presence" was the equivalent of a rounding error in a normal campaign budget.
It isn't quite as catchy as a bass solo (or men who look like Kenny Rogers for that matter) but pretty impressive, none the less.
** Semi-boutique: since these are really production line basses built by Gibson, but originally designed by Mike Tobias. He may have a pre-Gibson model, in which case, it's in great condition, and a boutique bass.
Read more...
Posted by
Bradley
at
8:58 PM
0
comments
Labels: politics
